Block 19

Solving Problems:
Option 1

Cognitive

One-to-One

Skill and Goal

Problem-solving
A toddler explores putting balls inside an angled tube and catching balls at the lower end of the tube.

Materials
Needed

  • Jumbo mailing tube (see Be Prepared)
  • 5–7 small balls
  • Large block or small box
  • 2 pails or containers

Key
Concepts

  • Inside
  • Outside
  • Tube
  • Roll

Also
Promotes

  • Physical / Health
  • Communication / Language

Be Prepared: A mailing tube of eight inches in diameter and 36 inches in length works well for this activity. Set up an attractive arrangement with a pail or container of the balls and the tube. Make sure the balls can easily roll through the tube. Place one end of the tube on the block or small box so the tube angles downward. Put supports on the sides of the tube resting on the box so it stays in place. Put the second (empty) pail near the lower end of the tube.

Begin:

[Invite a toddler to join you to play with balls and the tube. Point to the tube as you name it.]

Act:

This is called a tube. Watch what happens to our ball when I put it inside our tube.

[When the toddler is looking at the ball, put the ball in the upper end of the tube. Draw the toddler’s attention to the rolling ball at the lower end of the tube, if necessary.]

Our ball rolled inside the tube. It rolled to the other end of our tube. Now our ball is outside of our tube. We cannot see our ball when it is rolling inside our tube.

Would you like to put another ball inside our tube?

[If the toddler does not want to put a ball inside the upper end of the tube, encourage him/her to catch the ball when it rolls out of the lower end of the tube.

If the toddler opts to put a ball inside the tube, remain near the upper end of the tube to provide verbal guidance or hands-on support for putting the ball inside the hole of the tube.

If the toddler can readily put a ball in the tube, place the pail of balls near the upper end of the tube and then move to the lower end of the tube to catch balls the toddler puts in the upper end. Put balls in the second pail.

Describe the actions of the ball and the toddler. Emphasize the concepts of inside, outside, rolls down, comes out, and how we cannot see the ball when it is inside the tube.

Reverse roles, so the toddler catches balls you put in the upper end of the tube.]

Recap:

[Describe what happened. Example: “You put a lot of balls inside our tube. The balls rolled to the other end of our tube. Then you caught balls that rolled out of our tube. We could not see the balls when they were inside the tube.”]

What to Look For—Option 1

The two main ways for a toddler to participate in this simple activity—putting balls inside the tube and catching balls as they roll out—have valuable learning potential. Both contributions emphasize the invisibility of a ball as it rolls through the tube plus the anticipation and excitement of seeing the ball again at the lower end of the tube. The Enrichment tip of elevating the angle of the tube can indirectly support a toddler’s insight into the link between tube angle and speed of the ball. Catching balls as they roll out of the tube offers a different perspective on the ball rolling, and can help strengthen a toddler’s understanding of more when he/she puts the “caught” balls into the pail. It is fine if a toddler prefers to assume one of these two roles only.

Scaffolding tips

More Scaffolding Tips—Option 1

Extra support

  • In the opening segment of the activity, repeat putting a ball in the upper end of the tube if it appears the toddler would benefit from another demonstration.
  • Use gestures, as appropriate, when you ask the toddler if he/she would like to put a ball inside the tube.

Enrichment

  • Demonstrate lifting one end of the tube to make balls roll out faster. Encourage the toddler to lift the tube higher when he/she puts a ball inside the tube.
Block 19

Solving Problems:
Option 2

Cognitive

One-to-One

Skill and Goal

Problem-solving
A toddler explores rolling balls through tubes placed at different angles.

Materials
Needed

  • 2 jumbo mailing tubes (see Be Prepared)
  • 5–7 small balls
  • Large block or small box
  • 3–4 small blocks Pail or container

Key
Concepts

  • Push
  • Roll
  • Inside

Also
Promotes

  • Physical / Health
  • Communication / Language

Be Prepared: Secure identical mailing tubes. Tubes of eight inches in diameter and 36 inches in length work well for this activity. Put one of the tubes flat on the floor. Place the balls in the pail and put the pail near one end of a tube. Put the second tube and block (or box) nearby.

This activity option is designed to help a toddler explore how the angle of a tube is connected to whether and how fast a ball rolls through a tube. Your approach to the activity will depend on the toddler’s experiences with rolling balls, especially rolling balls through a tube (as in Option 1). Possibilities for supporting the toddler’s experiences in this activity are described below, listed from simpler to more complex arrangements. Use one or more of the possibilities in response to the toddler’s engagement in the activity. Consistently use gestures to complement your words.

Open the session by displaying and naming the tube, and encouraging the toddler to look into the tube. You may wish to move your hand or fingers on the opposite end of the tube to strengthen the toddler’s understanding that the tube is open at both ends. You also may wish to help the toddler stand the tube on one of its ends so it is straight up (vertical position) and drop a ball through the top of the tube to demonstrate the tube is open.

After a period of exploring the tube, offer one or more of the following arrangements:

  • Put the tube flat on the floor and gently push a ball into the tube. Use a light push so the ball does not roll out the other end of the tube. Explain that the ball is inside the tube. Suggest that the toddler lift one end of the tube. Draw attention to how the ball rolled out at the other end. Explain what happened. Repeat by gently pushing the ball into the tube. Again, encourage the toddler to lift one end of the tube to see what happens.
  • Raise one end of the tube using a block or box. You may need to loosely tape the tube to the box or block to keep it steady. Invite the toddler to put one or more balls through the tube. Describe what happens. (This is a repeat of Option 1.) Then help the toddler add 3–4 small blocks to raise the end of the tube even higher. The toddler may notice how the ball rolls faster when the end of the tube is higher. Invite the toddler to participate in both actions: putting balls inside the tube and catching balls as they roll out of the tube.
  • Place two tubes side by side, each with one end raised using a block or box. Then help the toddler add 3–4 small blocks to raise the end of one of the tubes higher than the other. Draw attention to how the end of one tube is higher than the end of the other tube. Invite the toddler to put one ball in each tube at the same time (or the toddler puts a ball in one tube and you put a ball in the other tube at the same time). Ask which ball rolls faster (comes out sooner). Repeat the rolling of balls in the two tubes at the same time.

What to Look For—Option 2

Any one of the segments of this activity may be an entire focus of a toddler’s actions. A toddler may be primarily interested in looking through a tube, maybe playing a form of Peek-a-boo with it. A toddler will be able to look through the eight-inch tube using both eyes, unlike narrow tubes. Or a toddler may wish to mostly push a series of balls through a tube that is flat on the floor, maybe lifting one end of the tube when a ball(s) does not roll out. In contrast, another toddler may wish to repeatedly watch what happens when balls are put in adjacent tubes, with one tube angled higher than the other. In general, follow the toddler’s lead with the tube(s) and balls, and look for ways to promote a toddler’s active problem-solving participation so the session does not become one of you demonstrating only.

Scaffolding tips

More Scaffolding Tips—Option 2

Extra support

  • In the first bulleted arrangement, your gentle push of the ball into the tube may prompt the ball to roll out of the other end. If this happens, explain that you pushed the ball with your hand and it rolled through the tube. Then again put the ball at one end of the tube and push the ball with less force so it (hopefully) does not roll to the other end of the tube and there is an opportunity for the toddler to lift the tube and find out what happens.

Enrichment

  • If a toddler shows interest in the angles of the tubes, encourage him/her to explore differences in angles by putting different numbers of small blocks under each of the two tubes.
  • When you present the tube at the beginning of the activity, introduce making a sound in the tube by lifting it to your mouth and saying “hello.” Hold the tube so the toddler has an opportunity to produce a sound. As a response to the toddler’s sound, whisper “hello.”

Interest Area

Materials Needed: tubes and balls used in Options 1 and 2, Where is Spot? by Eric Hill, Caps For Sale: A Tale of a Peddler, Some Monkeys and Their Monkey Business by Esphyr Slobodkina

In addition to exploring balls and tubes under close adult supervision, toddlers will enjoy books with flaps related to solving a problem, such as Where is Spot? The problem presented in the book is resolved. Mother dog looks in several places and finds the puppy. The Caps for Sale book also supports problem-solving skills.

Family Child Care

Family Child Care

Materials Needed: containers and small toys, small soft blocks, manipulative toys that connect— such as Mr. Potato Head®, bowling-type games, balls, and empty milk cartons.

The problem-solving skills promoted in this activity plan for toddlers may be enhanced with other types of materials for younger and older children in your setting. Infants enjoy dumping items out of containers and putting them back. Mobile infants will enjoy knocking down a stack of light blocks. Bowling-type games with balls and milk cartons are enjoyable for many children. Manipulative toys that fit together and come apart, such as Mr. Potato Head®, are enjoyable problem-solving tasks. When weather permits, preschool-age and older toddlers may enjoy going through a simple maze you create in the yard.